Showing posts with label media. Show all posts
Showing posts with label media. Show all posts

Monday, April 07, 2008

More Journalistic Impropriety

You should read the article first.

I think this is absolutely disgusting. First of all, this is hardly a big enough deal to write a story about. Secondly, it's one of the most obvious cases of a journalist losing impartiality that I've ever seen outside of local news outlets' treatment of local sporting events (with local teams playing out-of-towners).
But recent accounts of the episode have omitted key details that suggest there was more truth in the essence of Clinton's tale than her critics, and even her presidential campaign, have acknowledged.
I really think it's inappropriate for a journalist to be speaking about how much "truth" (which is obviously used metaphorically here) is in "the essence" of something. I read and re-read this section to determine whether or not they were quoting a Clinton campaign spokesperson. They weren't.

And again at the close of the article:
But according to Casto's account, Bachtel's medical tragedy began with circumstances very close to the essence of Clinton's now-abandoned account: the lack of insurance created a $100 barrier to needed medical attention close to home.
Again, the writer is talking about "the essence" of the story. And of course the writer decides what the essence of it is. The writer decided that "the essence" of the story is not that the woman was turned away from a hospital where she had never been before (presumably or impliedly at the ER) because she wouldn't pay up front. And that she tried again and was turned away again. No, of course not.

It's this kind of bullshit that makes me understand why we need Fox News.

Tuesday, October 18, 2005

The Problem with Journalists Today

As far as I can tell, there are five different, basic approaches to providing information:

1. You can give the facts without any spin
2. You can characterize the facts in a way that disposes others to believe what you want them to believe about the situation
3. You can just make sh*t up
4. You can pick certain facts and exclude others to give a spin on the situation
5. You can stretch the truth about the situation

Journalists are supposed to do #1. Traditionally, maybe they did, and maybe they didn't. If they didn't, then hopefully they at least tried to do that. Today, few journalists do.

Lawyers are supposed to do #2, and that's what we pay them to do. The right-wing media (by that I mean Fox) also tend to do this. This is fine, however, because people can easily see the bias and read between the lines to find the kernels of truth. And with this approach, the truth is still there.

The Weekly World News does #3. It's fine in this situaiton because everything they "report" is completely fake, and everyone knows it. Occasionally this method seeps into the mainstream media, and it does so more often now that most of the mainstream media outlets seem to be letting bloggers do their research for them. This makes it easy for a blogger to create a hoax, and they do this on a regular basis just to keep the news on their toes.

The media of the 80's and 90's tended to do #4, and this approach probably goes back much further. It's one of the most dangerous methods because it sounds like the whole truth and nothing but the truth, and if you don't hear the story from anywhere else then you will take it as the truth, without any indication otherwise.

The media of today are continually falling into method #5. This is usually the domain of comedians, but the media aren't trying to make you laugh. They're trying to convince you of something that isn't true, like, for example, that New Jersey is two-feet deep in water, or that the body count in NOLA is ten or fifty or a hundred times as high as it really is.

The so-called liberal media use tricks #4 and #5 almost exclusively, and it's dangerous. If you can't find any non-mainstream media outlet (or maybe PBS) that uses method #1, then go with the crazy right-wingers on Fox, because when somebody calls Bush a great man because of what he did today, you can decide for yourself whether to believe that characterization. It's less dangerous simply because it's obvious. Then check out the liberal media to see exactly what it is that they're hiding from you or lying about.

Monday, October 17, 2005

What Is Truth? What about Journalistic Integrity?

Found it here.
On the Today show this morning, Katie Couric was promoting a segment that would talk about the apparent staged inteview with soldiers in Iraq. A few moments later the show went to correspondent Michelle Kosinski, reporting on location about the floods in New Jersey. Kosinski was canoeing in what looked to be in deep water. However as the segment begin two men walked in front of her in what looked to be a few inches of water. Michelle Kosinski attempted to brush this off, however Katie and Matt couldn’t stop laughing about the situation.


I'm not sure if I can add anything to the utter irony and rank hypocrisy displayed here. Is this another symtom of whatever disease the news media as a group seem to have?
First, they take a real tragedy and multiply the death toll by about a thousand or more, so that when we know the truth it doesn't seem so bad. But because it seems so bad the ratings spike. When they do that, the plight of real people who suffer is minimalized. And what about this? Are we going to believe them the next time they report on a genocide in some tiny African country? (Of course, American journalists tend not to report on something like that. Unless it would make Bush look worse, which seems to be the media's top priority right now.)

Saturday, May 21, 2005

Television

This was originally posted over at The Considerations as a response to a post on A Plain View.

TV is not the devil. There is nothing inherently wrong with it, but something happened to it. As a kid, I watched "Full House" on a regular basis. Thinking back on it, it's kind of creepy that three young girls lived with their dad and two uncles, but the show was wholesome: there was always a lesson to be learned.
From Looney Toons I became acquainted with classical music (particularly Grieg), opera, and fine literature (including Steinbeck and Shakespeare).
Even G.I. Joe taught us that knowing is half the battle.
But now what does TV have to offer? Reality television, which has largely replaced the sitcom, does not conform to either "reality" or normal conventions of "television." It blurs the line between truth and fiction and toes the line of the legal "obscene." The producers want you to think that Paris spilled the ashes of a human being and gathered them up with a vacuum cleaner. In reality, it's just ashes that they told her to spill.
The same goes for current childrens' programming. The infamous Pokemon and the more recent Yu-Gi-Oh have no valuable life lesson at the end, only blatant marketing. In Pokemon you "gotta catch 'em all," and in Yu-Gi-Oh the characters actually play the game for which they sell cards.
What happened to books?
The point is this: in the end, the only television worth watching should make you laugh for 15 minutes to a half hour, and not force you to watch the next episode for fear of missing something important.
Either that, or it should be hosted by Alex Trebek (all other game shows will rot your brain).